Free Shipping On Orders Over $35

Custom Hair Color Set Reviews

3.0 out of 5 (1,008 ratings)

613 Client Reviews

Sort by:

Posted by: Matt S.
July 29, 2020

Darker than expected

Posted by: Matt S.
July 29, 2020

The application and instructions were super easy, but the color is much darker than expected. It says dark blonde, but my color turned out to be a brownish/red (I have red in my hair as well).

0 of 0 people found this review helpful. Did you?
Thank you, this review has been flagged. Undo
Posted by: Mauricio N.
April 10, 2025

Burned my hair!

Posted by: Mauricio N.
April 10, 2025

Not happy at all!

0 of 0 people found this review helpful. Did you?
Thank you, this review has been flagged. Undo
Posted by: Vadim P.
April 9, 2025

does not cover gray hair

Posted by: Vadim P.
April 9, 2025

hair dyed but does not cover gray hair

0 of 0 people found this review helpful. Did you?
Thank you, this review has been flagged. Undo
Posted by: Cecilia A.

Response From Our Experts

Posted by: Cecilia A.

Hi Vadim! We are sorry to hear your greys weren't fully covered. Please check your emails, we got back to you to help you further.

Posted by: Vinayak A.
February 25, 2025

For some reason it has stopped working

Posted by: Vinayak A.
February 25, 2025

Only colors 5-10% so essentially after the wash it doesn’t even look like my hair were colored. Really disappointed for last few times.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful. Did you?
Thank you, this review has been flagged. Undo
Posted by: Jasmine S.

Response From Our Experts

Posted by: Jasmine S.

Vinayak - We’re so sorry to hear that you were disappointed by the results of your color application. Our Color Happiness Guarantee is something we always stand behind, and we will work with you to meet your hair color goals. Your colorist will review your feedback and adjust the formulation for your next color order to deliver results better suited to your needs. We look forward to hearing your feedback on this new formulation soon.

Posted by: Chris B.
February 18, 2025

I guess the chemical based kits just aren't for me.

Posted by: Chris B.
February 18, 2025

Tried this instead of henna based kits and I didn't have great results and wasn't happy with the chemicals and how it affected my skin and hair.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful. Did you?
Thank you, this review has been flagged. Undo
Posted by: Elia M.

Response From Our Experts

Posted by: Elia M.

Chris - We’re so sorry to hear that you were disappointed by the results of your color application. Please keep your eye out for an email from us. We truly appreciate your feedback.

Posted by: Adam M.
February 5, 2025

Doesn’t work on short facial hair

Posted by: Adam M.
February 5, 2025

Really impressed with the box and packaging etc but unfortunately it hasn’t worked for me at all. Tried everything exactly as directed but the greys on my beard are exactly the same after use. I did specify short beard for my order, pretty disappointing.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful. Did you?
Thank you, this review has been flagged. Undo
Posted by: Cecilia A.

Response From Our Experts

Posted by: Cecilia A.

Hi Adam! We are so sorry to hear it didn't work on your facial hair. Please check your emails, we got back to you to help you.

Posted by: Matthew M.
January 22, 2025

Not long lasting

Posted by: Matthew M.
January 22, 2025

After a few attempts got the colour right but it sadly doesn’t last very long, coloured a week ago and already the grey is coming back through with a vengeance. Easy to apply, and initial results seem ok but in natural light it may as well not be there.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful. Did you?
Thank you, this review has been flagged. Undo
Posted by: Cecilia A.

Response From Our Experts

Posted by: Cecilia A.

Hi Matthew! We are so sorry to hear your greys are back so quick. Please check your emails, we got back to you to help you.

Posted by: Saffy
January 17, 2025

Scammers

Posted by: Saffy
January 17, 2025

A scam company who should be shut down adds autoship without notification and steals your money.... 50% bad reviews on Trustpilot says it all... I've also added my negative review on Facebook and Trustpilot....

0 of 0 people found this review helpful. Did you?
Thank you, this review has been flagged. Undo
Posted by: Cecilia A.

Response From Our Experts

Posted by: Cecilia A.

Hi Saffy! We are sorry to hear about your personal experience using our services. We've got back to all of your messages. Please let us know if there's anything else, we can do for you.

Posted by: Geoff B.
January 13, 2025

Unwanted delivery and charge

Posted by: Geoff B.
January 13, 2025

I signed up for a trial and the product burned my skin and was expensive. I then got another box, I thought it was a mistake, then I got another. I contacted them for a refund and got no response

0 of 0 people found this review helpful. Did you?
Thank you, this review has been flagged. Undo
Posted by: Jacquelyn T.

Response From Our Experts

Posted by: Jacquelyn T.

Hello Geoff, We truly appreciate your feedback! Upon reviewing your profile, we see that you have already worked with one of our Color Experts to resolve your concern. Please let us know if there is anything else we can do to help!

Posted by: Frank C.
January 10, 2025

terrible color

Posted by: Frank C.
January 10, 2025

wanted medium ash brown, results were dark, dark brown or black Had to wear a cap for Holidays.

0 of 0 people found this review helpful. Did you?
Thank you, this review has been flagged. Undo
Posted by: Jacquelyn T.

Response From Our Experts

Posted by: Jacquelyn T.

Hello Frank, Thank you for your feedback on your color. Here at Colorsmith, we are always striving to improve, and ensure each and every customer is 100% satisfied with their color! We are so sorry to hear that we haven’t got it just right with your color. You are fully covered by our Color Happiness Guarantee, and one of our Color Experts has sent you an email to get this resolved for you. We appreciate you reaching out!

This website uses cookies

This website uses cookies and similar technologies to operate our site and services, optimize the website, monitor sessions, enhance your experience, and for marketing. These technologies may monitor your use of the site and share that information with third parties, including for analytics, social media, and advertising purposes. For more info, including on data retention, see the privacy notices linked below. Click “Cookie Settings” to opt-out of certain advertising cookies. By accessing or using the website, you agree to the use of cookies to collect and share your information, and to our Terms of Use (including arbitration & class waiver terms), Privacy Policy and (for California residents) the CA Privacy Notice.